I have been researching organisations and their cultures for more than ten years and I am fascinated by the fact that the organisations that are heralded as truly innovative, vibrant and exciting are few and far between. There is so much knowledge out there about how to create forward-thinking and successful organisations, companies spend millions each year on consultants to help them with this pursuit - yet I would argue that the list of those who can be truly admired is not very long.
It is of course very difficult to really know what a company is really like without working in it, Reading books. articles and case studies is not enough, Nor is attendance at conferences where company representatives speak about their success and how they achieved it. I have read and heard lots of very positive stories about companies who I doubt could live up to those stories. Corporate PR machines are alive and kicking.
Notwithstanding that, the following companies are probably justifiably admired and certainly very attractive to prospective investors, customers and employees:
- Google
- Apple
- SAS Institute
- Southwest Airlines
- Ritz-Carlton
- Virgin
- WL Gore
All of these companies appear to have innovation in their history and in their blood stream. They don’t have to engage in the so-called ‘war for talent’, they have people queuing up to work for them.
Most of them are American. Why is that? Is it to do with the American culture, the best of which is positive, optimistic, boundary-breaking and can-do. It strikes me when working with American colleagues that they focus on what they can do, not what they can’t, they celebrate success and push for more and they don’t consider modesty to be a virtue.
In contrast, some would say that the worst of British culture means that people famously favour the underdog, play down success, stick with tried and tested ways of doing things and are conscious of their place in the prevailing hierarchy’.
Of course, generalisations are dangerous but there does seem to be something worth thinking about here. It is common for business leaders to ask themselves what they can learn from other companies, it is a good question. The context cannot be overlooked though - national culture is a crucially important part of that context and can undoubtedly shed some light on differences that make a difference.
Sally